Williamsville might be known for its charming village vibe and top rated schools, but it is also home to some of the best pizza in Western New York. From classic Buffalo style spots that have been around for decades to fresh new concepts bringing Mediterranean flair, this village has a slice for every craving.

Whether you are a potential homebuyer scouting the neighborhood or a local looking for a new favorite spot, here is where to find the best pizza in Williamsville.

Key Takeaways

• Williamsville has everything from classic Buffalo style pizzerias to Mediterranean inspired pies and Italian pinsas.
• Muscarella's Pizza and Sorrentino's Pizzeria are frequently called hidden gems by locals.
• Ana Blu Mediterranean Pizzeria and Forno e Mercato are exciting newcomers that opened in 2025 and 2026.
• LaPorta's Pizzeria has been a family owned favorite since 1986.
• D'Avolio Kitchen boasts an impressive 4.7 star rating.
• Buffalo style pizza features a thick crust that is crispy on the outside and chewy on the inside.

The Hidden Gems Locals Swear By

Muscarella's Pizza at 5526 Main Street is the definition of a hidden gem. Local residents have made it one of the most popular spots in the area, with reviewers calling it a must try. The pizza is described as very good, solid, medium thick buffalo pizza with extremely fresh and bountiful toppings. The cup and char pepperoni is a standout, and the Italian wings are top notch. One reviewer noted it was significantly more affordable than some competitors.

Sorrentino's Pizzeria at 5640 Main Street is another spot that flies under the radar. It has been a local favorite since 1976, renowned for its Buffalo NY style pizza and delectable wings. The crust is described as perfectly thin, not too thin, and great for grabbing with your fingers. Patrons rave about the generous antipasto and the signature chicken finger pizza. With reasonable prices and a lovely patio for summer dining, families return time and again.

The Long Standing Favorites

LaPorta's Pizzeria is a Williamsville institution. Family owned since 1986, it is celebrated for its authentic pizza and subs. With a rating of 4.4 stars from over 230 reviews, customers praise the fresh ingredients and homemade dough. One loyal customer says the quality has remained high throughout the years, and every bite transports them back to their childhood. The atmosphere is warm and welcoming, making it a favored spot for both casual dining and quick takeout.

D'Avolio Kitchen at 5409 Main Street boasts an impressive 4.7 star rating. While listed as an Italian restaurant, one reviewer notes it is really a pizza joint. They have a build your own menu for flatbread style pizzas with a vast assortment of toppings. The food is described as excellent with wonderful cheese and great red sauce. They also offer vegan options, making it a great choice for groups with different dietary needs.

La Nova Pizzeria at 5151 Main Street is part of the famous Buffalo chain known for its thin crust and signature pies. Their pizza is considered some of the best in the area, but their BBQ chicken wings are also stars of the show. The wings are deep fried, coated in a thick and sweet BBQ sauce, and then finished over a grill.

Pizza Plant Italian Pub at 7770 Transit Road offers a cozy atmosphere with vintage design elements, serving stuffed pizzas and a variety of bar food alongside craft beers. Family owned since 1980, they started with the Chicago Style Stuffed Pizza. Their garlic dough for bread bowls, pods, and pizzas comes highly recommended.

Santora's Pizza Pub Grill at 7800 Transit Road offers a great patio with live music and a lively atmosphere. They have gluten free options and free WiFi.

The Newcomers Making Waves

Ana Blu Mediterranean Pizzeria at 5110 Main Street is the latest concept from the creators of Giancarlo's Sicilian Steakhouse. Inspired by the Mediterranean coast, their menu features both thin New York style and thick Sicilian style pizzas. The NY style Mediterranean pizza is topped with feta, olives, lamb meatball chunks, and a tahini citrus drizzle. The Sicilian style Cappicola features fresh mozzarella, cherry peppers, vodka sauce, and pesto oil. It is a fast elegant concept with prices that will not break the bank. Open for lunch Tuesday through Saturday.

Forno e Mercato at 5225 Sheridan Drive is an Italian café and market from the owners of Frankie Primo's +39. They offer Italian pinsas, fresh bread and pasta made daily, homemade Italian cookies and pastries, espresso and coffee, and gelato. The space is designed for grab and go convenience. They also offer a beer and wine menu coming soon, as well as hands-on classes including pasta making and traditional Italian baking.

A Note on Buffalo Style Pizza

If you are new to the area, you might be wondering what makes Buffalo style pizza different. The crust is kind of in the middle, thicker than New York style but not as thick as a Chicago deep dish. It is crispy on the outside and chewy on the inside. This is the style you will find at many of Williamsville's classic pizzerias like Muscarella's and Sorrentino's.

FAQ

Q: What is the best pizza place in Williamsville?
A: That depends on what you are looking for. Muscarella's Pizza is frequently called a hidden gem with the most flavor and crispy pepperonis. D'Avolio Kitchen has the highest rating at 4.7 stars. LaPorta's Pizzeria has been a family-owned favorite since 1986. And for something new, Ana Blu Mediterranean Pizzeria is getting a lot of buzz.

Q: Where can I get Buffalo style pizza in Williamsville?
A: Muscarella's Pizza serves classic Buffalo style pizza with cup and char pepperoni. Sorrentino's Pizzeria is also known for its Buffalo NY style pizza. La Nova Pizzeria is another great option for Buffalo style thin crust.

Q: Are there any new pizza places in Williamsville?
A: Yes. Ana Blu Mediterranean Pizzeria opened recently, bringing Mediterranean inspired thin and Sicilian style pizzas. Forno e Mercato is also new, offering Italian pinsas and grab and go Italian fare.

Q: Where can I get gluten free pizza in Williamsville?
A: LaPorta's Pizzeria offers gluten free pizza with a flavorful, not too dense crust. Santora's Pizza Pub Grill also serves gluten free meals.

Q: What is the most underrated pizza place in Williamsville?
A: Muscarella's Pizza is frequently described as a hidden gem. Sorrentino's Pizzeria is also a spot that flies under the radar with a loyal local following.

Q: Is there a Detroit style pizza place in Williamsville?
A: Yes, Jet's Pizza at 5401 Sheridan Drive is one of the original purveyors of Detroit style pizza and has a location in Williamsville.

Q: Where is the best place for pizza and beer?
A: Pizza Plant Italian Pub offers a cozy atmosphere with stuffed pizzas and craft beers. Santora's Pizza Pub Grill also has a great patio with live music.

Q: What is the best value pizza in Williamsville?
A: Muscarella's Pizza is notably more affordable than some competitors. Sorrentino's Pizzeria is also known for reasonable prices and generous portions.