Amherst and Williamsville might be known for their top rated schools and beautiful homes, but they also quietly have some of the best breakfast scenes in Western New York. From European inspired cafes and South Asian fusion spots to classic diners and a legendary pancake house, these neighboring communities serve up morning meals that keep locals coming back week after week. Here is where to go for a great start to your day.
Key Takeaways
- The Original Pancake House has locations in both Amherst and Williamsville and is considered a breakfast institution.
- Masuda's Cafe in Amherst opened in 2025 and offers South Asian influenced breakfast dishes.
- Filled With Love Cafe and Market in Williamsville is a European inspired cafe and market featuring tartines and specialty groceries.
- Ohlson's Bakery and Cafe in Amherst serves breakfast and lunch in a cozy, bakery setting.
- Andy's Sunrise Diner in Williamsville is a family owned diner with a loyal following.
- Several spots offer gluten free, vegan, and European style options for diverse tastes.
The Heavy Hitters
The Original Pancake House is the undisputed king of breakfast in this area, with locations in both Amherst and Williamsville. Their signature Apple Pancake is legendary, featuring thick slices of Granny Smith apples baked into a giant pancake and drenched in a sticky, buttery cinnamon glaze. They also serve Dutch Babies, crepes, Swedish pancakes with lingonberries, and omelets made with fresh ingredients. Everything is made fresh to order, from batters prepared daily to homemade sauces and syrups. The Williamsville location is at 5479 Main Street and the Amherst location is at 2075 Niagara Falls Boulevard.
Ohlson's Bakery and Cafe at 8500 Sheridan Drive in Amherst is a charming spot known for its warm atmosphere and friendly service. This bakery serves breakfast and lunch, featuring items like pancakes and sandwiches alongside an impressive variety of baked goods. Their menu includes cupcakes, pies, breads, cookies, and pastries, with a reputation for beautiful wedding cakes and delicious cupcakes. It is described as having a cozy, grandma's living room vibe combined with a neighborhood cafe. They are open Monday through Friday from 8 AM to 5 PM and Saturday from 8 AM to 3 PM.
The Newcomers
Masuda's Cafe at 17 Kellogg Avenue in Amherst opened in June 2025 and brought something fresh to the breakfast scene. Named after owner Masuda Abdullah, the cafe serves North American breakfast classics blended with vibrant South Asian flavors, honoring her Afghan roots . One of her favorite menu items is the spicy tomato poached egg dish, a traditional Afghan breakfast. Other offerings include bolani, an Afghan flatbread stuffed with spiced potatoes and herbs, as well as unique fusion items like French toast with cardamom and saffron. They are open Tuesday through Sunday from 7 AM to 5 PM.
Filled With Love Buffalo Cafe and Market at 962 Maple Road in Williamsville is a European inspired cafe and market that found its footing in 2024. Founded by Ukrainian refugee Karina Krantz, the cafe emphasizes local, organic, or European products. The menu centers on European style tartines, which are open faced sandwiches like the Slavic Smash with avocado and dill, and The Tuscan Brie with prosciutto and truffle oil. They also offer espresso drinks, smoothies, and curated shelves with European pantry items. Guests can round up their purchases to support the International Institute of Buffalo.
The Hidden Gems
Sheridan Family Restaurant at 3901 Sheridan Drive in Amherst is a Greek and American restaurant serving breakfast, lunch, and dinner. Reviewers praise the generous portions, friendly service, and excellent omelettes and corned beef hash. It is open daily from 7 AM to 8 PM.
Williamsville Favorites
SPoT Coffee in Williamsville is a popular American eatery with an inviting atmosphere, great coffee, and yummy breakfast options. Their omelettes are especially great, and they are open daily from 7 AM to 8 PM.
Acropolis Opa at 5429 Main Street in Williamsville is a Greek restaurant serving breakfast on Saturdays with traditional and healthy options, fresh fruit, and great Peet's coffee. Their homemade hummus is a standout.
A Note on Break'n Eggs Creperie
Break'n Eggs Creperie, which was previously listed as a Williamsville favorite, closed its Williamsville location in September 2024 after losing its lease. However, their Amherst location at 1280 Sweet Home Road remains open and serves the same sweet, savory, and gluten free crepes that made them popular.
FAQ
Q: What is the best breakfast place in Amherst?
A: The Original Pancake House is consistently a top choice. For something different, Masuda's Cafe offers unique South Asian influenced dishes, and Ohlson's Bakery and Cafe is a cozy local favorite.
Q: Where should I go for pancakes in Williamsville?
A: The Original Pancake House on Main Street is the answer. Their oven baked Apple Pancake is legendary, and they also serve Swedish pancakes with lingonberries and a variety of other styles.
Q: Are there any unique or international breakfast spots in the area?
A: Yes. Masuda's Cafe in Amherst serves South Asian influenced breakfast with dishes like spicy tomato poached eggs and bolani. Filled With Love Buffalo Cafe and Market in Williamsville offers European style tartines and specialty groceries.
Q: What is a good family friendly breakfast spot?
A: Ohlson's Bakery and Cafe and Andy's Sunrise Diner are both described as family friendly with warm atmospheres and menus that appeal to all ages.
Q: Where can I get a classic diner breakfast?
A: Andy's Sunrise Diner in Williamsville is a classic family-owned diner with outstanding service. Sheridan Family Restaurant in Amherst also serves classic breakfast comfort food.
Q: Are there gluten free or vegan breakfast options?
A: Yes. Break'n Eggs Creperie serves gluten free crepes at their Amherst location. Filled With Love and Masuda's Cafe emphasize fresh ingredients with vegan and gluten free options available.
Q: What is the newest breakfast spot in the area?
A: Masuda's Cafe opened in Amherst in June 2025 and Filled with Love Buffalo Cafe and Market relocated to Williamsville in 2024.
Check out this article next
