Elmwood Village is known for being one of Buffalo's most walkable neighborhoods, and its coffee scene is a big reason why locals and visitors keep coming back. Whether you are looking for a cozy spot to work, a place to meet friends, or just a great cup of coffee to go, this neighborhood has options worth exploring.

From long standing institutions to newer spots that have quickly become favorites, here is a look at some of the best coffee shops in Elmwood Village.

Key Takeaways

• Elmwood Village has a Walk Score of 89, meaning most coffee shops are within a short walk.
• Overwinter Coffee is a local favorite known for its cozy Victorian atmosphere and creative seasonal drinks.
• SPoT Coffee has been a neighborhood staple for 30 years with a full food menu.
• Tipico Coffee is a renowned roastery with a bright, open space and direct trade beans.
• Caffe Aroma is a community hub with poetry readings and a strong, robust coffee.
• All of these shops are locally owned, so you are supporting small businesses.

Overwinter Coffee

Overwinter Coffee is the kind of place that feels like stepping into someone's beautifully decorated living room. Located in a converted Victorian era home at 814 Elmwood Avenue, this spot has a cozy, inviting atmosphere that keeps people coming back. It is right across from the Lexington Co op, making it a convenient stop for Elmwood strolling.

The coffee at Overwinter is made with high quality, single origin beans roasted locally. Regulars rave about the oat milk latte, the rosemary vanilla latte, and the ube latte with a pump of vanilla. They also offer seasonal syrups like salted caramel pumpkin and creative drinks like an espresso tonic with orange syrup. Pastries include gluten free and vegan options.

The service is generally friendly and knowledgeable, though a few reviews mention occasional inconsistencies. The space can feel a bit tight when it is busy, but the atmosphere makes up for it.

Address: 814 Elmwood Ave, Buffalo, NY 14222
Hours: 8 AM to 4 PM, seven days a week 

SPoT Coffee

SPoT Coffee has been a fixture in Elmwood Village for 30 years and is considered Buffalo's original craft coffee establishment. Located at 765 Elmwood Avenue, this spot has a cozy neighborhood vibe with ample seating for working or socializing.

The menu is extensive, with breakfast options, sandwiches, salads, pizza, and desserts alongside the coffee drinks. Seasonal drinks like pumpkin pie and white chocolate pumpkin mocha are popular. Prices are reasonable, and there is a loyalty program called SPoT Coins for regulars.

Reviews are mixed. Some customers love the atmosphere and friendly staff, while others note occasional inconsistencies with drink quality and service. The grilled cheese sandwich, once a favorite, has changed and disappointed some longtime customers.

Address: 765 Elmwood Ave, Buffalo, NY 14222
Hours: 7 AM to 8 PM daily

Tipico Coffee

Tipico Coffee is a renowned café and roastery located at 1084 Elmwood Avenue. The space is described as "wide open spaces filled with light," making it a great spot if you prefer a brighter, more open atmosphere. They opened their Elmwood Village location in 2020 after starting on the West Side.

Tipico takes its coffee seriously. They source beans directly from a family in Costa Rica and have been nominated for a Good Food Award for their Guatemalan Las Moritas blend. The menu includes premium coffees, specialty toast, sandwiches, and sides. Customers recommend the maple and brown sugar overnight oats and the maple bun latte.

The staff is friendly and fast, though seating can be limited during peak times. Weekend hours start at 8 AM, which some find a bit late.

Address: 1084 Elmwood Ave, Buffalo, NY 14222
Phone: (716) 464-3449 

Caffe Aroma

Caffe Aroma is a community institution that has been a cherished café for over 20 years at 957 Elmwood Avenue. It is known for its strong, robust coffee and warm, inviting atmosphere. The space is European style with art on the walls and regular poetry readings and open mic nights.

The coffee is famously strong, and they serve Italian sipping chocolate for those looking for something different. The location is great for people watching, and the outdoor seating is popular. Breakfast sandwiches and quick bites are available.

Caffe Aroma has new ownership as of summer 2023, but the new owner has been part of the establishment for years. Some reviews mention variable food quality and occasional service issues, but the coffee and atmosphere remain strong draws. The shop hosts art markets on Monday evenings with local vendors and live music.

Address: 957 Elmwood Ave, Buffalo, NY 14222
Phone: (716) 884-4522
Hours: Vary by day, generally 6 AM to 10 PM or midnight

Blue Mountain Coffees

Blue Mountain Coffees is a long standing shop at 509 Elmwood Avenue that has been in business since 1981. This spot is known for its excellent customer service and a wide selection of whole bean coffees, teas, and unique gifts.

While coffee is the star, tea enthusiasts will appreciate their high-quality loose teas, including the notable Monk's Blend, at fair prices. The staff is friendly and knowledgeable, making it a great place to go if you want to take home good beans or find a gift.

Address: 509 Elmwood Ave, Buffalo, NY 14222

FAQS

Q: Which coffee shop has the best atmosphere for working?
A: Overwinter Coffee is known for its cozy, quiet atmosphere with comfortable seating that is good for getting work done. SPoT Coffee also has ample seating.

Q: Do these coffee shops have alternative milk options?
A: Yes. Overwinter Coffee offers oat milk, almond milk, coconut milk, and other alternatives. Most other shops in Elmwood Village also carry alternative milks.

Q: Are there gluten free or vegan options?
A: Overwinter Coffee is known for having gluten free and vegan pastries. Most shops have some dietary friendly options.

Q: Which coffee shop is best for people watching?
A: Caffe Aroma is often called a great spot for people watching, dog petting, and good vibes in general. It is right in the heart of Elmwood Village.

Q: Where can I buy good coffee beans to take home?
A: Overwinter Coffee sells bags of their beans. Blue Mountain Coffees has a wide selection of whole bean coffees and loose teas.

Q: What are the best unique drinks?
A: Overwinter's rosemary vanilla latte and ube latte get frequent mentions. Caffe Aroma's Italian sipping chocolate is also well regarded.